Back to News

You Have Received Your Tax Assessment – What If You Disagree?

You open your mailbox and find the final assessment decision for your income and wealth taxes. On review, you notice that something is wrong. A deduction is missing, an item of income has been set too high, or the tax authority has simply not accepted your figures. What now? This article is for private individuals and business owners in Switzerland. It explains which legal remedies are available, what matters when you file an objection (known in German as “Einsprache”), and which opportunities and risks you should weigh before doing so.

What is an assessment, and why is it binding?

Through the assessment (“Veranlagung”), the tax authority formally determines your taxable income and wealth and the amount of tax you owe. This decision replaces your tax return as the authoritative basis for your tax liability.

The tax authority reviews your declarations and may depart from them. If the assessment deviates to your disadvantage, you have the right to challenge it. If you do not react, however, the decision becomes final and binding (“rechtskräftig”). It can then be corrected only in very narrow exceptional cases.

The objection as the first legal remedy

The first and most important remedy against an assessment is the objection (“Einsprache”). With it, you ask the same authority that issued the assessment to review its decision again. Swiss law provides this remedy for the direct federal tax as well as for cantonal and communal taxes. Switzerland has a three-tier tax system, and these levels are levied side by side.

An objection can be kept simple. Even so, it pays to observe a few formal points carefully, so that the authority actually considers your request on its merits.

Which deadline applies, and why it is decisive

The objection period is 30 days. It starts on the day after the assessment decision was delivered to you. This is a statutory deadline and cannot be extended.

What counts is the moment you file the objection. If you send it by post, the postmark date applies. If you miss the deadline, the assessment becomes final, however well founded your concern may be on the substance.

Only a person who was prevented through no fault of their own from filing on time, for example because of serious illness, may request restoration of the deadline, and only under strict conditions. This is the exception, not the rule.

What requirements must your objection meet?

For the authority to deal with your objection, it should contain several elements. The following items belong in an objection:

  • Identification of the contested assessment (tax year, date and reference of the decision)
  • A clear request: what exactly should be changed?
  • A statement of reasons: why do you consider the assessment wrong?
  • The necessary evidence or documents, such as receipts for deductions or proof of income
  • Your signature and the date

Special case: challenging a discretionary assessment

If you filed your tax return late, not at all, or only incompletely, the authority may estimate your income and wealth at its dutiful discretion. This is called a discretionary assessment (“Ermessensveranlagung”) or official estimate.

Stricter requirements apply to challenging such an assessment. You cannot simply claim that the estimate is too high. The law requires you to prove that the estimate is manifestly incorrect.

In practice, this usually means that you must submit the missing tax return and provide all the missing supporting documents in full. An objection that merely states reasons is generally not enough here. This higher hurdle makes challenging a discretionary assessment considerably more demanding than challenging an ordinary one.

Opportunities and risks: what to weigh before filing

An objection offers the chance to have an incorrect assessment corrected without great effort. The objection procedure is generally free of charge. The authority does not normally levy fees for it, unlike in later court proceedings.

There is, however, one significant risk. The authority does not just look at the point you raised. It reviews the entire assessment. If it finds an error in your favor, it may also correct the assessment to your disadvantage, so a worse outcome is possible.

A sober assessment is therefore advisable before you file:

  • Can the disputed point be clearly proven with documents?
  • Does the assessment contain other items that are wrong in your favor and might be noticed during a review?
  • Is the potential tax saving reasonable in relation to the effort involved?

What comes after the objection?

If the authority rejects your objection in whole or in part, you receive an objection decision (“Einspracheentscheid”). You can challenge it within 30 days by filing an appeal (“Beschwerde” or “Rekurs”) with an independent cantonal body. This is usually a tax appeals commission or a cantonal administrative or tax court.

From this stage, the procedure becomes more formal and may involve procedural costs. Professional support is often advisable here at the latest. The route to the Federal Supreme Court remains open for matters concerning the direct federal tax or questions of federal law.

Check every assessment immediately upon receipt and note the end of the 30-day period. If you disagree with an item, collect the supporting documents and set out your request and reasons clearly in writing. For a discretionary assessment, submit the missing tax return together with the supporting documents. Seek professional advice before filing if substantial amounts are at stake, if your assessment contains other sensitive items, or if an official estimate is in play. We are happy to help you evaluate your prospects of success and draft a well-founded objection. This article provides general information and does not replace advice on your individual case.

Contact Person

Contact our professional experts

post 1

Michael AngehrnAttorney at Law, Partner

michael.angehrn@amatin.ch
+41 61 202 91 80

SecureFileTRANSFER

Contact us

Contact Form